Curling shingles, in short
Curling shingles are shingles whose edges or corners have lifted away from the roof instead of lying flat. On an older roof in Scottsdale they are usually a sign of age: the asphalt has dried and shrunk under years of heat and sunlight. On a newer roof they more often point to a problem with the product or the installation.
Either way, curling matters because a lifted edge is where wind gets in. A curled shingle has lost some of its seal and some of its flexibility, and in a monsoon gust it is far more likely to crack, tear or blow off than one that lies flat.
This article explains what makes shingles curl, the difference between the two main kinds of curling, what the pattern across a roof tells you, and when curling means repair or replacement. It describes nothing to do on the roof, because that is work for someone equipped for it.
Two kinds of curl
Curling takes two forms. Cupping is when the edges of a shingle turn upward and the middle stays down, so the shingle looks like a shallow dish. Clawing is the opposite: the middle lifts while the edges stay down, so the tabs look like they are gripping the roof.
The distinction is useful because the two can have different causes, although both end in the same place. Either way, the shingle is no longer lying flat, its seal is compromised, and its surface is under strain that will eventually crack it.
On a 3-tab roof the curl is easy to see along the line of the tabs. On an architectural roof it can be harder to spot because the surface is irregular by design, and curling may show as lifted corners or uneven shadow lines.
Both kinds are visible from the ground in low sunlight, which throws lifted edges into shadow.
Heat is the main cause here
At the Scottsdale Municipal Airport weather station, NOAA’s 1991 to 2020 normals average about 93 days a year at or above 100 degrees Fahrenheit and about 161 days at or above 90 (NOAA NCEI). Phoenix-area figures add 21 days a year at or above 110 degrees (NWS Phoenix).
A shingle is asphalt held in a mat and surfaced with granules. Heat and sunlight drive the oils out of the asphalt over time, and as it dries it shrinks and stiffens. Because the top surface is exposed and the underside is not, the two faces age differently, and that uneven shrinkage pulls the shingle out of flat.
Granule loss speeds it up. The granules are what shield the asphalt from ultraviolet light, and once they have shed the asphalt beneath ages faster. That is why curling and granule loss on shingles so often appear together.
On a roof that has spent fifteen or more summers here, some curling is an expected stage of ageing rather than a surprise.
Heat from below plays a part
A shingle roof is heated from above by the sun and from below by the attic. A City of Scottsdale homeowner guide describes heat in the attic expanding and contracting the roof structure and working nails loose over time. The same heat bakes the underside of the deck and the shingles on it.
An attic that holds a great deal of heat makes the shingles above it run hotter than they otherwise would, which can speed up drying and curling. Attic ventilation affects that, although it is a separate subject and not one this article goes into.
Moisture from below can contribute too, though it is a smaller factor in a dry climate than in a humid one. Annual rainfall at the Scottsdale station is only 8.73 inches, so moisture-driven curling is less common here than heat-driven curling.
The practical point is that curling is not always only about the shingle. Sometimes the roof assembly is part of the cause.
Curling on a newer roof is a different problem
When a roof that is only a few years old starts curling, age is not the explanation. The usual suspects are installation and product: shingles fastened incorrectly, nails placed too high or too few, shingles laid over an uneven surface or an old layer, or a defective batch of product.
Overlays can contribute. A City of Scottsdale homeowner guide permits a maximum of one asphalt shingle overlay over one existing shingle roof, and shingles laid over old ones sit on an uneven base that can make them curl or lift sooner.
A newer roof with curling is worth having looked at promptly, because the cause may be covered by a workmanship or product warranty. Keep the paperwork from the installation, including the product details.
Arizona law allows a complaint to be filed with the Registrar of Contractors within two years after a project is completed (Arizona Revised Statutes 32-1162), which makes prompt attention more important.
Other signs that travel with curling
Curling rarely appears alone. On an ageing shingle roof it usually arrives alongside other signs of the same process, and seeing them together helps judge how far along the roof is. Granules collecting in gutters or at the base of downspouts are the most common companion, followed by cracking across the shingle face.
Bald patches, where the dark asphalt shows through because granules have gone, mark the areas ageing fastest. Shingles that look brittle or broken at their corners, and nail heads visible where they should be covered, suggest the roof has reached the stage where wind will start to remove pieces.
Inside, a stain that appears only during heavy, wind-driven rain often means water is getting under lifted shingles and past the underlayment. Stains in more than one place point at the roof as a whole rather than one damaged spot.
Taken together, these signs describe a roof’s position in its life far better than its age on paper.
The pattern across the roof is a clue
Where curling appears matters as much as how much. Curling spread evenly across the slopes that face the sun most suggests ordinary heat ageing. Curling concentrated in one area may point to a local cause, such as heat building in one part of the attic, a problem with the deck beneath, or an installation fault on that section.
South and west facing slopes take the most sun here, and they usually age first. If curling is confined to them and the other slopes still look sound, the roof is ageing as expected and the shaded slopes have more life left.
Curling only along the edges or ridge may relate to how those courses were fastened. Curling around vents, pipes or skylights may relate to the details there.
That pattern is something a roofer reads when deciding between repair and replacement, and it is why photographs of every slope help.
A curled shingle is a wind risk
The City of Scottsdale homeowner guide names wind as the most damaging element in the southwestern desert. The NOAA Storm Events Database records 659 thunderstorm wind reports in Maricopa County between 2016 and 2025 (NOAA NCEI), which are reports rather than every event.
A flat shingle presents almost nothing for wind to catch. A curled one has an edge raised into the airflow and a seal that is already partly broken. In a strong gust it flexes, cracks along the lifted edge, and can tear free or lift the shingle above it.
That is why a roof with widespread curling often loses shingles in its first serious monsoon storm, even though it seemed sound the week before. The storm exposes the weakness rather than creating it.
What to look for after that kind of storm is covered in wind damage to shingles.
Repair or replace
A few curled shingles on an otherwise sound roof can usually be replaced individually. The difficulty is that on an older roof, the shingles around them are often brittle too, and removing one can crack its neighbours. Matching weathered colour and profile can also be hard.
Widespread curling across the sun-facing slopes of an older roof is different. It means the asphalt across the roof has reached the same stage, and patching one area only waits for the next. At that point replacement is usually the honest recommendation.
Curling also suggests the underlayment beneath has spent the same years in the same heat. That layer is covered in shingle underlayment, and it is the part a replacement renews along with the shingles.
For what a shingle repair or replacement involves on a particular house, see our asphalt shingle roofing in Scottsdale page.
Curling and insurance
Owners often ask whether curling is something to claim for. The 2015 Arizona Department of Insurance guidance says homeowners policies generally cover only the portion of a roof damaged by falling objects, rain, snow or wind (Arizona Department of Insurance). Curling caused by age and heat is wear rather than storm damage, which places it outside that description.
That distinction matters if curled shingles are later damaged or removed by wind. An insurer may look at whether the roof was already worn when the storm arrived, which is one reason to record a roof’s condition before problems occur.
That guidance dates from 2015, and the department is now part of the Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions. Policies vary, so confirm with your own insurer what your policy covers.
Photographs of every slope, dated, are the simplest record of condition you can keep.
Where to start
Look at the roof from the ground in early morning or late afternoon light, which shows lifted edges as shadows. Note which slopes are affected and how widely. Check gutters for granules, which often accompany curling.
If curling is spread across the sunny slopes of an older roof, plan for replacement before the next monsoon rather than after it. If the roof is newer, have the cause looked at and find the installation paperwork. The wider picture is in our guide to metal and shingle roofing in Scottsdale.
One safety point. Curled shingles are brittle and slippery underfoot, and the City of Scottsdale’s homeowner guide says roof work can be dangerous and lethal for the inexperienced. If you would rather have someone look at it, Residential Roofing Scottsdale works across Scottsdale and the surrounding Valley. Call (480) 919-1173.
Frequently asked questions
These are the questions homeowners in this area ask most often when they first notice the edges of their shingles lifting. Each answer is kept deliberately short, and the sections above go into more detail for anyone who wants the full explanation before deciding what to do next.
What causes shingles to curl?
On an older roof, mostly heat and sunlight drying the asphalt so it shrinks unevenly. Granule loss, heat from the attic below and age all add to it. On a newer roof, installation problems or a product defect are more likely causes.
What is the difference between cupping and clawing shingles?
Cupping is when a shingle’s edges turn up and the middle stays down. Clawing is when the middle lifts while the edges stay down. Both mean the shingle is no longer lying flat and has lost some of its seal.
Do curling shingles mean I need a new roof?
A few curled shingles on a sound roof can be replaced individually. Curling spread across the sunny slopes of an older roof usually means the shingles have reached the same stage everywhere, and replacement is the more sensible plan.
Can curled shingles be flattened or repaired?
A curled shingle has dried and shrunk, so it cannot be returned to its original condition. Individual shingles can be replaced, but on an older roof neighbouring shingles are often brittle and crack when disturbed.
Are curling shingles a problem in monsoon season?
Yes. A lifted edge catches wind and has already lost part of its seal, so curled shingles are much more likely to crack or blow off in a strong gust. A roof with widespread curling is worth addressing before the monsoon.
Does insurance cover curling shingles?
Curling from age and heat is wear rather than storm damage. The 2015 Arizona Department of Insurance guidance says policies generally cover roof damage from wind and similar causes. Policies vary, so confirm with your own insurer.
